Religious Researches

Religious Researches

A Study on How the Sentences Are Carried Out for a Muhârab and the Conformity of the Method of Choosing Graded Punishments with That of Alternative Punishments

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
Mohammad Hossein Shaker Ashtijeh 1
Hamid Roostaei Sadrabadi 2
1 Ph.D Student, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, Ayatollah Haeri University, Meybod, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies. Ayatollah Haeri University, Meybod, Iran
10.22059/jorr.2020.295408.1008690
Abstract
Regardless of what the nature of muhârabah is, this study examines four punishments for a muhârab, i.e. execution, crucifixion, cutting off, and exile. As for the method of choosing one of the punishments, based on Qur’anic verses, Islamic narrations, logic, and the demands of Islamic law (Shari'ah) some have acknowledged the grades and some have acknowledged the alternatives for a judge to choose one of the punishments. For carrying out each and every one of the sentences, we face questions and ambiguities regarding how punishment is carried out with Arabic language pattern “taf'īl”, the possibility of surviving after the punishment is carried out and suggestions about preventing that, whether carrying out punishment is the right of God or the right of people and what the consequences are, how to crucify or exile, cutting off when the organ is absent, the way that choosing how to carry out an alternative punishment is matched with the concept of fixed punishments prescribed by Allah, the possibility of anesthetizing for executing a fixed punishment, and whether the cut organ is a punishment for the community or the muhârab. Using a library method of research, this paper examines the solution for removing the conflict between two groups of arguments for having the option to execute alternative punishments or graded punishments and for solving the problem of logical improbability by proposing a comprehensive method of executive judgment. While examining how every one of the punishments is executed, the existing ambiguities and subsidiary issues are responded and some legislative suggestions to be included in the coming reforms of the penal code are made. 
Keywords
Punishment of a Muhârab
Execution
Crucifixion
Exile
Grade
Choosing

  1. The Holy Quran

    1. Ibn Abi Jame, A. (1993). Al-Wajiz Fi Tafsir the Holy Quran, Qom: Dar al-Quran al-Karim Publishing. (in Arabic)
    2. Ibn Idris, Halli, M. (1990). Al-Saraer Al-Hawi Letahrir al-fatwas, Qom: Islamic Publications Office Publishing. (in Arabic)
    3. . Araki, M. A. (1994). Esteftaat, Qom: Famous Publishing. (in Arabic)
    4. Bojnurdi, Sayyid M.(. (1981 al-Ghavaed al-Feqhi, Tehran: Ascension Publishing. (in Arabic)
    5. Isfahani, Fazel Hindi, M. (1996). Kashf al-Lesam Va al-Ebham An Ghavaed al-Ahkam, Qom: Islamic Publications Office Publishing. (in Arabic)
    6. Jorjani, Abu A. ibn M. (1983). Tafsir Shahi Ao Ayat al-Ahkam, Tehran: Navid Publishing. (in Persian)
    7. Jazayeri, N. (2009). Oghod al-Marjan Fi Tafsir al-Qur'an, Qom: The Light of Revelation Publishing. (in Arabic)
    8. Halli, Ibn Idris, M. (1990). Al-Sarawi Al-Hawi Letahrir al-Fatwa, Qom: Islamic Publications Office Publishing. (in Arabic)
    9. Halli, Allama, H. (1991). Tabserato al-Motaallemin Fi Ahkam al-Ddin, Tehran: Publishing Institute affiliated to the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance. (in Arabic)
    10. Halli, Allama, H. (1993). Gjavaed al-Ahkam Fi Marefat al-Halal Va al-Haram, Qom: Islamic Publications Office Publishing. (in Arabic)
    11. Halli, M. (2004). Kanzo al-Erfan Fi Feghhe al-Qur'an, Qom: Mortazavi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    12. Khansari, Sayyid A. (1985). Jameo al-Madarek Fi Sharhe al-Mokhtasaro al-Nafe, Qom: Ismaili Institute Publishing. (in Arabic)
    13. Khomeini, Ruhollah Mousavi. (bita). Tahriro al-Vasilah, Qom: Dar Al-Alam Publishing. (in Arabic)
    14. Khoi, Sayyid A. (2002). Mabani Takmelato al-Menhaj, Qom: Institute for the Revival of the Works of Imam Al-Khoei Publishing. (in Arabic)
    15. Ravandi, Qutbuddin, S. (1985), Fiqho al-Quran, Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Library Publishing. (in Arabic)
    16. Sheibani, M. (1993). Nahjo al-Bayan An Kashfe al-Maane al-Qur'an, Qom: Al-Hadi, peace be upon him Publishing. (in Arabic)
    17. Saduq, Qomi, M.(1995). Almoghna, Qom: Imam Hadi Institute, peace be upon him Publishing. (in Arabic)
    18. Tabatabai, M. H. (2003). Translation of Tafsir Al-Mizan. Mousavi Hamedani, Qom: Islamic Publications Office. (in Persian)
    19. Tusi, Abu J. M. (2008). Al-Mabsot Fi Feqhe al-Imamiah, Tehran: Mortazavi Library Publishing. (in Arabic)
    20. Tusi, Abu J. M. (1980). Al-Nahayah Fi Mojarrade al-Feqhe Va al-Fatwa, Beirut: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    21. Ameli, Harr, Mu. (1989). Tafsile al-Vasayelo al-shiah Ela Tahsile al-Masayelo al-Shariah, Qom: Al-Bayt Foundation, peace be upon them Publishing. (in Arabic)
    22. Ameli, Shahid Thani. Za. (1990). al-Rawdah al-Bahiyyah Fi Sharh al-Lama'a Dameshghiyah, Qom: Arbitration Publishing. (in Arabic)
    23. Ameli, Shahid Thani. Za. (1993). Masaleko al-Ahkam Ela Tanghihe Sharayeo al-Eslam, Qom: Islamic Knowledge Publishing. (in Arabic)
    24. Fadhil Jawad, J. (1986). Masaleko al-Ahkam Ela Ayate al-Ahkam, Tehran: Mortazavi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    25. Fakhr al-Muhaqiqin, Halli. M. (2008). Izaho al-Ghavaed Fi Sharhe Moshkelato al-Ghavaed, Qom: Ismaili Institute Publishing. (in Arabic)
    26. Qaraati, M. (2009). Tafsire Noor, Tehran: Cultural Center for Lessons from the Quran Publishing. (in Persian)
    27. Qomi Mashhadi, M. (1989). Tafsire Kanzo al-Daghaegh Va Bahro al-Gharaeb, Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Guidance Publishing. (in Arabic)
    28. Kashani, Faiz, M. M. (Bita). Mafatih al-Sharia, Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Library Publishing. (in Arabic)
    29. Kashani, Faiz, M. (1994). Tafsir al-Safi, Tehran: Sadr School Publishing. (in Arabic)
    30. Gorgi, A. (2006). Ayato al-Ahkam (legal and penal). Tehran: Mizan Publishing. (in Persian)
    31. Golpayegani, Seyed M. R. (1992). Al-Dorrol al-Manzood Fi Ahkamel al-Hodood, Qom: Dar Al-Quran Al-Karima Publishing. (in Arabic)
    32. Goldoost Joybari, R. (2009). Crimes against national security, Tehran: Jangal Publishing. (in Persian)
    33. Mohaqeq Halli, Najmuddin, J. (1988). Sharayeo al-Islam Fi Masayele al-Halal Va al-Haram, Qom: Ismaili Institute Publishing. (in Arabic)
    34. Makarem Shirazi, N. (1995). Tafsire Nemoone, Tehran: Islamic Books House Publishing. (in Persian)
    35. Makarem Shirazi, N. (1992). Majmoe Esteftaat Jadid, Qom: Imam Ali Ibn Abi Talib Alayhamassalaam School Publishing. (in Persian)
    36. Najafi, M. H. (1984). Javahero al-Kalam Fi Sharhe Sharayeo al-Eslam, Beirut: House for the Revival of Arab Heritage Publishing. (in Arabic)
    37. Najafi, Kashif al-Ghatta ', J. (2002). Kashfo al-Gheta An Mobhamate Shari'a al-Ghara, Qom: Publications of the Office of Islamic Propaganda of the Seminary of Qom. (in Arabic)
    38. Matlabi, M; Moradkhani, A; Shafiee Mazandarani, Seyed M. (2020). “A study of the jurisprudential and legal principles of human ownership of the body” Jurisprudential Research, 16(1), 173- (in Persian)
    39. Makarem, N. (1995). Tafsire Nemoone, Qom: Islamic Books House. (in Persian)
    40. Hashemi Shahroudi, M. (1999). Essentials of Criminal Jurisprudence, Tehran: Mizan Publishing-Justice Publishing. (in Persian)
Religious Researches
Volume 17, Issue 3
Autumn 2021
Pages 771-800

  • Receive Date 18 January 2020
  • Revise Date 13 May 2020
  • Accept Date 18 May 2020