A Review of Retaliation without Ruler's Permission from Muhaqiq Ardebili’s Viewpoint and Islamic Penal Code Approved in 2013

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D Student of jurisprudence and principles of Islamic law, Islamic Azad University, Torbat Heidarieh Branch, Torbat Heidarieh, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of jurisprudence and principles of Islamic Law, Islamic Azad University, Torbat Heidarieh Branch, Torbat Heidarieh, Iran

3 Professor, Department of jurisprudence and principles of Islamic law, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran

Abstract

There is consensus among scholars according to the stipulated text of the Divine Legislator regarding the retaliation right for the avenger of blood. However, there are controversies among the scholars as to whether it is necessary for the avenger of blood to seek the religious ruler's permission for the execution of retribution (qisas). The jurists have proposed some opinions in this respect. The majority of jurists such as Shaik Tusi maintain that the ruler's permission is obligatory in both issuance of the verdict and its execution. Other jurists such as Muhaqqiq Hilli maintain that the ruler's permission is obligatory only in the phase of issuance of the verdict. A few number of jurists such as Muhaqqiq Ardibili have mentioned that it is not obligatory for the avenger of blood to seek the ruler's permission in any phase. This research has used an analytical library research method. Having discussed the jurists' opinions and their arguments, the research aims at answering the question as to which opinions are acceptable based on rational and transmitted evidences and from which of the mentioned opinions the Islamic Penal Code is adopted. The research findings show that the famous opinion is valid and justifiable regarding the reasonable transmitted and rational indications and that the Islamic Penal Code 2014 is adopted from this opinion. In addition, it can be understood that Muhaqqiq Ardibili's opinion lacks validity. 

Keywords

References

- Holly Quran
1. Amoli, Mohammad Ibn Maki. (1989). Al-Lomah al-dameshqiya fi feqh al- Imamiya, Beirout: Dar al-trath al- Islamiya. (in Arabic)
2. Amoli, Zainodin Ibn Ali. (1989). Al-Rouzah al-Bahiyah Fi sharhe al-Lomah-al-Dameshqiyah, Vol. 10, Qom: first edition. (in Arabic)
3. Amoli, Zainodin Ibn Ali. (1992). Masalek al-Afham ela Tanqih Sharaye al-Islam, Vol. 15, Qom: Pasdar of Islam. (in Arabic)
4. Amoli, Javad Ibn Mohammad Hosseini. (n.d). Meftah al-kearamah fi Sharh Qavaed Allamah, Beirut: dar ehya al-trath al-arabic, first edition. (in Arabic)
5. Allameh Helli, Hassan Ibn yousof. (2000). Tahrir al-ahkam, Research: Ebrahim Bahadori, Qom: Imam Sadiq Institute. (in Arabic)
6. Allameh Helli, Hassan Ibn yousof. (1991). Qavaed Al-Ahkam Fi Marefah al-Halal and al-Haram, Qom: Islamic Publications. (in Arabic)
7. Allameh Helli, Hassan Ibn yousof. (1992). Mokhtalef al- shiah fi ahkam al- shariah, second edition, Qom: Islamic Publications.(in arabic)
8. Amid Zanjani, Abbassali. (2009). Ayaat al Ahkam(Legal-Criminal), Editor: Abolfazl Ahmadzadeh, Tehran: Majd publication. (In Persian)
9. Fazel Lankarani, Mohammad. (1999). Tafsil Al-Sharia fi Sharh Tahrir al-vasila, Qom: center of the Imams. (in Arabic)
10. Fazel Hindi. Mohammad Ibn Hassan. (1995). Kashf al-letham an qawaed al-ahkam, Qom: Institute of Islamic Publications. (in Arabic)
11. Fazel Meqdad, Meqdad Ibn Abdollah. (2003). Kanz al-erfan fi feqeh al-quran, Vol. 2, Qom: Mortazavi Publishing. (in Arabic)
12. Fazel Abi, Hassan Ibn Abitaleb. (1996). Kashf al-romoze, Qom: Institute of Islamic Publications. (in Arabic)
13. Faiz Kashani, Mohammad mohssen. (n,d). Mofatih al-Sharaye, Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Publishing House, First edition. (in Arabic)
14. Faiz, Alireza. (1989). Moqarene va tatbiq in the Public Penal Law of Islam, Second Edition: Tehran Publishing. (in Arabic)
15. Golpayegani, Mohammadreza. (1984). Book Al-Shahadat, Qom, First Edition. (in Arabic)
16. Goldouziyan,Irag. (2016). Mohashay Islamic Penal Code. (In Persian)
17. Helli, Mohammad Ibn Hassan Ibn yousof, Fakhr al-Muhaqiqin. (1966). Iyzah al-Favaeid, first edition.Qom: Esmaeilian. (in Arabic).
18. Haeri Tabatabaei, Ali Ibn Mohammad. (1997). Riyadh al-Massael fi bayan al-Ahkam: Vol.16, Qom: Al-bait institute, first edition. (in Arabic)
19. Horr Amoli, Mohammad Ibn Hassan. (1988). vassael al-Shiah, Vol 30, Al -bait Institute, Qom: First edition. (in Arabic)
20. Helli, Yahya Ibn saeid. (1984). Aljame L-sharaye. Qom: institute of Sayyid al-Shohada Alamiyah, first edition. (in Arabic)
21. Halabi, Taqiyodin Ibn Najmodin. (1982). Al-Kafi fi al-Feqh, Isfahan: General library of Imam Amir al-Muminin, first edition. (in Arabic)
22. Hosseini shirazi, Mohammad. (1986). Al-feqh: mousue estedlaliya fi al-feqh al-Islami, Qom: al-fekr al-islami. (in Arabic)
23. Hosseini nik, Abbass. (2017). Collection of practical rules of Majd, Tehran: Majd Publishing. (In Persian)
24. Hashemi Shahrudi, Mahmoud. (1998). Criminal jurisprudence, Tehran: mizan Publishing, First Edition. (In Persian)
25. Ibn Idriss, Mohammad Ibn Mansour. (1989). Assaraer al-havi Ltahrir al-fatawa, Vol3, Qom: Islamic publishing office affiliated to the Qom Seminary Teachers Society, Second Edition. (in Arabic)
26. Ibn Baraj, Abdolaziz. (1985). al-Mohazzab, Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute. (in Arabic)
27. Ibn Zohreh, Hamzah Ibn Ali Hosseini. (1996). Qonya al-nozue, Qom: Imam Sadeq Publishing. (in Arabic)
28. Ibn Manzoor, Mohammad Ibn Mokarram (1987). Lesan al-arab, Dar ehya al-trath al-arabic, Beirut. (in Arabic)
29. Ibn Fahad, Helli Ahmad Ibn Mohammad. (1996). Mohzzab al-Barea, Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Qom Seminary Teachers Society. (in Arabic)
30. Koleini, Mohammad Ibn yaqoub. (1986). Al-kafi, Vol 8, Tehran: Dar al-Kotob al-Islamiya, Fourth Edition. (in Arabic)
31. Khansari, Saiyed Ahmad. (1984). JameoMaddark fi Sharhe of Al-Nafa. Qom: Ismailiyan Institute. (in Arabic)
32. Khoei, Abolqasem. (1982). Mabani Takmelah al-Minhaj, First edition, Qom: Al-Imam alKhooi Institute. (in Arabic)
33. Majlisi, Mohammad Taqi. (1983). Merat al-oghoul fi Sharh Al Akhbar Al-Rasul, Vol 26, Tehran: Darolkotob al-Islamiyah, Second Edition. (in Arabic)
34. Majlisi, Mohammad Taqi. (1985). Rozah al-Motaqin Fi, Sharhe Man La Yahzoroh al-Faqih, Vol.13 Qom: Islamic Cultural Institute of Kushanbur, Second Edition. (in Arabic)
35. Modarresi, Tabatabaei Hossein. (1889). Introduction to Feqh-Al Shieh, Translator, Mohammad Asef Fekrat, Mashhad, Astan Quds Razavi Publishing. (In Persian)
36. Madani Kashani, Reza. (1989). Book Al-Qasas foqaha and Al-Khawas, Qom: Islamic Publications Institute. (in Arabic)
37. Muhaqiq Ardebili, Ahmad Ibn Mohammad. (n.d). Zobdat al-bayan Fi Ahkam al-Quran, Tehran: al-Maktaba al-Ja'fariyah. (in Arabic)
38. Muhaqiq Ardebili, Ahmad Ibn Mohammad. (1982). Majma al-Faedeh al-Borhan fi Sharhe Ershad Al-Azhan, Vol.14, Qom: Islamic Publishing House affiliated with the community of lecturers of Qom Seminary, first edition. (in Arabic)
39. Muhaqiq Helli, Jafar Ibn Hassan. (1987). Sharaye al-Islam al-fi massael al-Halal al-Haram, Tehran: Esteghlal Publishing. (in Arabic)
40. Mofid, Mohammad Ibn noeman. (1992). Al-Maqneah. Qom: World Hazara Congress of Sheikh mofid, First Edition. (in Arabic)
41. Moqnieh, Mohammad Javad. (1981). Feqh, Al-Emam Ja'far al-Sadeq, Beirut: Dar al-Javad. (in Arabic)
42. Mosavi Khomeini, Rouhollah. (1987). Tahrir al-wasila, Qom: Ismailiyan Institute. (in Arabic)
43. Mir Mohammad Sadeqi, Hossein. (2013). Special Criminal Law, Tehran: Mizan Publication. (In Persian)
44. Momen, Mohammad. (1995). Permission of the leader in retribution, Fiqh of ahl al- bayt Journal, (3). (in Persian)
45. Najafi, Mohammad hassan. (1983). Jawaher al-Kalam fi Sharhe sharaye al- Islami, Vol. 43, Beirut: Seventh Edition. (in Arabic)
46. Naraqi, Ahmad Ibn Mohammad. (1994). Mostanad Al Shi'a fi Ahkam al-Shariah, Vol.19 Qom: Al-beyt Institute, first edition. (in Arabic)
47. Sabzevari, Ali Momen Qomi. (1999). Jame al-khalaf and al-wefagh, Qom: zaminesazan zohour imam. (in Arabic)
48. Tabatabaei yazdi, Mohammad Kazem. (1993). Takmelah al- orwah al-wothqa, Qom: Bookstore davari. (in Arabic)
49. Tabarsi, fazle Ibn Hassan. (1987). tafssir majma al-bayan, Rasouli, Fazlollah,yazdi . Beirut: Dar al-Marafah, Second Edition. (in Arabic)
50. Tabrizi, Javad Ibn Ali. (2004). Tanqih mabani al-ahkam, Second Edition, Qom: dar al-sediqa al- shaida. (in Arabic)
51. Tussi, Mohammad Ibn hassan. (1986). Al-Khalaf, Vol.6, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, first edition. (in Arabic)
52. Tussi, Mohammad Ibn Hassan. (1966). Al-Mabsut Fi Feqh Al-Imamiah, Vol. 8, Tehran: Jafariah Publications. (in Arabic)
53. Tussi, Mohammad Ibn Hassan. (1996). Al-Eddah fi osoul al-fegh, Research: Mohammad Ansari Qomi . (in Arabic)
Religious Researches
Volume 17, Issue 2
July 2021
Pages 677-708

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 02 February 2020
  • Revise Date: 26 April 2020
  • Accept Date: 26 April 2020

Share

How to cite

Statistics