Territory of Supervision over the Judge (Arbitrator) in Jurisprudence and Case Law

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor, Department of Law, Islamic Azad University, Saveh Branch, Saveh, Iran

2 Ph.D Student in Private Law, Islamic Azad University, Saveh Branch, Saveh, Iran

Abstract

Although arbitration is as old as the history of mankind, much of what we know today as arbitrator in Islamic texts is the result of ijtehad of Islamic jurists that established this institution in the periods of jurisprudence. Despite the similarities and differences, the relation between this institution in Islamic jurisprudence and the institution of arbitration in the present case law must be regarded as a continuation of the old law in the new law. Because the outstanding features and elements of today's arbitration including the mutual consent of the parties to the arbitration as well as the issuance of verdict on the basis of fairness and justice, has also existed in arbitration in the past. However, there are essential differences between the issue of jurisdiction over arbitration in the past with that in the present, the most obvious reason for which is the absence of the phenomenon of modern government and the modern judicatory system which considers one of its duties to oversee the process of arbitration in the positive and negative manner. 

Keywords

References

  1. Al-Golpayegani, Sayyid Muhammad Reza (1401 AH). Book of Judgment, vol. 1, Khayyam Press, Qom.(in Arabic)
  2. Al-Madrasi, Sayyid Muhammad Taqi (1431 AH). Islamic jurisprudence (Al-Risalah Al-Amli), Central Center, vol. 3, Beirut.(in Arabic)
  3. Al-Ruhani, Sayyid Muhammad Sadegh (pbuh) Complete the curriculum of the righteous in the rulings of the judiciary, martyrdom, limits, retribution, and guardianship, Press, etiquette, vol. 1, Najaf.(in Arabic)
  4. Al-Shahid Al-aval, the Damascus branch in the jurisprudence of the Imams, Dar al-Tarath al-Dar al-Islamiyyah, vol. 1. (in Arabic)
  5. Al-Shahid Al-sani (1413 AH). Problems of understanding until the revision of Islamic law, Islamic Knowledge Foundation, Qom.(in Arabic)
  6. Al-Sind, Sheikh Muhammad (1433 AH). Al-Hakimiyah between Al-Nas and Al-Dimqratiya, Al-Amira Publisher, Beirut.(in Arabic)
  7. Amandad, Majid Vanjehpour, Javad and Asadi Koohbad, Hormoz (2015). “The jurisprudential position of the private judicial system based on the institution of consolidation from the perspective of Imami jurisprudence”, Quarterly Journal of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, No. 16, pp. 9-33.(in Persian)
  8. Amir Moazi, Ahmad (2013) International Commercial Arbitration, Justice Publishing, First Edition.(in Persian)
  9. Ardabili, Sayyid Abdul Karim Mousavi (1423 AH). Jurisprudence, Volume 1, Al-Jame'a Al-Mufid Publishing Institute, Qom.(in Arabic)

10. Ayatollah Javadi Amoli, Abdullah (1391). Judicial Literature in Islam, Esra Publishing Center.(in Persian)

11. Brisen,S (1968). The Juridical nature of Private Arbitrationits Protection mage and Practice xi,BCA.

12. DAM Liu, Julian, E. Mistles Lucas, M. Kroll, Stephen (2012). Comparative International Commercial Arbitration, translated by Habibi Majandeh Mohammad, Mofid University Press, first edition.(in Persian)

13. Darvish Hoveida, Yousef (2009). Alternative Dispute Resolution Methods, Mizan Publications, First Edition.(in Persian)

14. Dehghani, Hamidreza (2012). “Documents of the condition of masculinity in the judge of consolidation from the point of view of Imami jurists”, Journal of Legal Research, No. 59, pp. 441-491.(in Persian)

15. Derakhshannia, Hamid (2018). The role of courts in arbitration (providing a suitable model), Dadnameh Publications, first edition.(in Persian)

16. Devichi, R (1965). Jacqueline ,l'arbitrage nature juridique, droit interne et droit international prive.

17. Domke,M (1968). The Law and Practice of Commercial Arbitration,Chicago.

18. Habibnejad, Seyed Ahmad and Bakhrd, Mostafa (2017).”Jurisprudential Study of Transaction in Non-Islamic Courts”, Quarterly Journal of Jurisprudential Research, Volume 13, Number 2, Pages 341-363.(in Persian)

19. Haeri, Sayyid Kazem (1415 AH) Judgment in Islamic jurisprudence, Islamic Thought Complex, Qom.(in Arabic)

20. Hooshmand Firoozabadi, Hossein and Batahi, Farhad (2017). “A Study of the Jurisprudential Nature of Arbitration”, Quarterly Journal of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, No. 48, pp. 171-192.(in Persian)

21. Izadifard, Ali Akbar and Fallah, Akbar and Khazaei Pool, Safar (2009). “The Legitimacy of Private Judgment in Islam”, Quarterly Journal of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, No. 18, pp. 69-96.(in Persian)

22. Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar (1999). Extensive in Legal Terminology, Ganj-e-Danesh Publications, Volume 3, First Edition.(in Persian)

23. Jafarian, Mansour (1994). “Reflections on the International Commercial Arbitration Bill”, Journal of Parliament and Strategy No. 14, pp. 99-126.(in Persian)

24. Junidi, Leia (2001).” International Commercial Arbitration Law from the Perspective of Islamic Law”, Matin Research Journal, No. 10, pp. 127-138.(in Persian)

25. Karimi, Abbas and Parto, Hamidreza (2014). Internal Arbitration Law, Publication of Justice, Third Edition.(in Persian)

26. Katozian, Nasser (2014). General Rules of Contracts, Volume III; Works of the contract, Publishing Joint Stock Company, ninth edition.(in Persian)

27. Khoei, Sayyid Abu al-Qasim(2007), Judgment and Martyrs, Islamic Khoei Foundation, vol 1.

28. Khudabakhshi, Abdullah (2018). Requirements of Comparative Arbitration Law, Anteshar Co., First Edition. (in Persian)

29. Mohammadi Khorshidi, Mohammad (2016). Arbitration in Iranian Law, Behnami Publications, Second Edition.(in Persian)

30. Mohaqeq Hali (1409 AH). Sharia of Islam in the issues of halal and forbidden, vol. 4, Esteghlal Publications, Tehran.(in Arabic)

31. Mousavi Ardebili, Abdul Karim (2002). Jurisprudence of jurisprudence, Bicha, Al-Mufid Society-Publishing Institute, Volume 1.(in Arabic)

32. Najafi, Mohammad Hassan (1988). Jawahar al-Kalam fi Sharh Sharia al-Islam, research: Sheikh Abbas Quchani, vol. 4, ch. 3, Tehran, Islamic Bookstore.(in Arabic)

33. New UNCITRAL Rules on International Arbitration (2014) Translated and researched by Dr. Mohsen Mohebbi and Hossein Kaviar, Khorsandi Publications, First Edition.(in Persian)

34. Olumi Yazdi, Hamidreza and Derakhshannia, Hamid (2018). “Court Intervention in Arbitrator Appointmen”, Pathology of Law, Judicial Procedure and Model, Quarterly Journal of Private Law Research, No. 22, pp. 87-114.(in Persian)

35. Poor Qassab Amiri, Ali and Izadi, Mohammad Rasoul (2015). Methods of Resolving International Trade Disputes, Majd Publications, First Edition.(in Persian)

36. Sadat, Mohsen (2010). “The article should be a new look at arbitration in legal jurisprudential research”, Jurisprudence Quarterly, No. 4, pp. 61-101.(in Persian)

37. Sangalji, Mohammad (2005). Judgment in Islam, University of Tehran Press, Fourth Edition.(in Persian)

38. Shams, Abdullah (2003). “Arbitration and Jurisdiction Agreement”, Journal of Legal Research, No. 37, pp. 9-44.(in Persian)

39. Sheikh Ahmad bin Muhammad Al-Ardabili (Holy Al-Ardabili) (1403 AH). The collection of benefits and proofs in the explanation of the guidance of the minds, Islamic Publishing Foundation, vol. 12.(in Arabic)

40. Sheikh Ja'far al-Subhani (1418 AH). Judicial system and martyrdom in Islamic Sharia al-Ghara, Imam Sadiq (AS) Institute, Qom.(in Arabic)

41. Sheikh Tusi, Abu Ja'far, Muhammad ibn Hassan (2008). Al-Mabsut Fi Al-Imamiya Fiqh, Volume 8, Al-Muktabah Al-Mortazavia, Tehran.(in Arabic)

42. Sheikh Tusi, Abu Ja'far, Muhammad ibn Hassan (2018). Al-Khalaf, Volumes 4 and 6, Islamic Publications Office of the Seminary Teachers Association, Qom.(in Arabic)

43. Taskhiri, Mohammad Ali and Mushirfar, Shiva (1997). “Arbitration in Islamic jurisprudence”, Islamic Research Quarterly, No. 1 and 2, pp. 179-222.(in Persian)

44. Tavakoli, Mohammad Mehdi (2016). Arbitrator installation, rulings and its works, Mizan Publications, first edition.(in Persian)

45. UNCITRAL model law on international commercial Arbitration 1985 with amendment as adopted in 2006.

46. Yazdani, Mohammad Karim (1960). “Conditions and Attributes of a Judge in Islamic Jurisprudence and Law”, Journal of the Bar Association, No. 71, pp. 20-23.(in Persian)

47. Yousefzadeh, Morteza (2014). Arbitration, Publication Co., Second Edition.(in Persian)

Religious Researches
Volume 17, Issue 2
July 2021
Pages 383-407

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 17 September 2019
  • Revise Date: 01 December 2019
  • Accept Date: 01 December 2019

Share

How to cite

Statistics