Measuring the Proportion of Barriers to Civil Liability to Reasons of Delictual Liability Relying on Imam Khomeini’s View

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Payame Noor University, Iran

2 Invited Instructor, Department of Law, Mofid University, Iran

Abstract

The barriers to civil liability are divided into two categories. The factors in which the requirement of responsibility and the civil liability elements (detriment, tortuous act, and causality) are not complete and has been harmed by one of the pillars of it. There are other factors that despite the existence of all the civil liability elements, civil liability is removed from them due to lawful and legal reasons. When measuring the proportion of the first group of factors to the reasons of liability we obtain specialized departure, and when measuring the proportion of the second group of factors to the reasons of liability we obtain allocated departure. This differentiation has some effects. The relation between the two categories and the evidence of liability “´Alal yadi ma akhaztu hatta tu`diyahu” and the rule “man atlafa malal ghayr fahuwa lahu zamin” and the rule “la zarar wa la zirar” is the relation between allocation and specialization. Although there was no specific confirmation of some of the factors of prohibition of civil liability, it can be concluded from the words of the jurists and Imam Khomeini (R.A.).

Keywords

References

  1. ARSHADI, ALIYARI.(2014). Civil Law Description Course: Coercive Guarantee and Civil Liability.Tehran:Behnami Publishing. (in Persian)
  2. Alzoheili,vahbe. (1981). Guarantee theory or civil and criminal liability provisions in Islamic jurisprudence. Damascus: Darolfekr Publishing. (in Arabic)
  3. Alseraj, Halaabdollah. (2013). It is necessary to make a mistake from the pillars of the responsible responsibility. Palestine: Al-Azhar University. (in Arabic)
  4. Al-Sanhouri, Abdul Razzaq Ahmad, (1949), Al-Wasit Fi Sharh Al-Qanun Al-Madani Al-Jadid, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo. (in Arabic)
  5. Esfehani, mohammad hosein, (1996). The footnote to the al makaseb, qom: Anvarolhoda Publishing. (in Arabic)
  6. Esfehani, Sheykh Alshariat, (1989). The rule of La Zarar, qom: Jameat Almodarresin Publishing. (in Arabic)
  7. Ansari, Morteza. (No printing date(. The rule of La Zarar, Al Yad, Al Sehat, Al ghorat, qom: Jameat Almodarresin Publishing. (in Arabic)
  8. Al Faghih, Mohammad Tghi. (1407). The rule of Feqh. Beirut: Dar Alazva Publishing. (in Arabic)
  9. Bariklu, Alireza. (2006). Civil liability. Tehran: Mizan Publishing. (in Persian)

10. Borujerdi, Hosein. (2008). Jame Al Ahadis al shia. Tehran: Farhang Sabz Publishing. (in Arabic)

11. Bahrami, Ahmad. (2009). Rules of Feqh (La Zarar) by applying the laws and comparative study. Tehran: University Imam sadeq. (in Persian)

12. Talmasani,efaf. (2014). The error of the injured and its effect on civil liability. Algeria, University of Oran. (in Arabic)

13. Jad Alhagh, Ayad mohammad. (No printing date(.How imperative (error) is as a pillar of negligence in the Palestinian civil law draft. (in Arabic)

14. Haeri, Seyed Mohammd. (No printing date). Al Manahel. Qom: Alolbeit Publishing. (in Arabic)

15. Hor Ameli, Mohammad. (1409). Vasaeloshiat. Qom: Alolbeit Publishing. (in Arabic)

16. Helli, Shamsodin. (2004). Maalemodin Fe feqhe Ale Yasin. Qom: Imam Sadegh Publishing. (in Arabic)

17. Hamad Shararat, Aboljabar. (1998). The theory of Nafy Al Zarar in comparative Islamic jurisprudence. Tehran: Association of Culture and Islamic Relations. (in Arabic)

18. Khalesi,  Mohammad Baqer. (1995). Lifting the ambiguity from the rule of La zarar. Qom: : Jameat Almodarresin Publishing. (in Arabic)

19. Akhond Khorasani, Mohammad Kazem. (1989). The rule of La Zarar. Qom: Alolbeit Publishing. (in Arabic)

20. Khomeini,  Rohollah. (2000). The Ten Epistles. Qom: Foundation for the Organization and Publishing of Imam Khomeini Antiquities. (in Arabic)

21. ________________. (2005). Tahrir Alvasilat. Qom: Jameat Almodarresin Publishing. (in Arabic)

22. ________________ (2001). Ketab Al beye. Qom: Foundation for the Organization and Publishing of Imam Khomeini Antiquities. (in Arabic)

23. ________________ (1996). Jurisprudence rules, diligence and tradition. Qom: Esmailiyan Publishing. (in Arabic)

24. ________________. (1997). Ketab Al beye. Qom: Foundation for the Organization and Publishing of Imam Khomeini Antiquities. (in Arabic)

25. ________________ (1994). Al Makaseb Al Moharamah. Qom: Foundation for the Organization and Publishing of Imam Khomeini Antiquities. (in Arabic)

26. Khoyi, Abolghasem. (No printing date). The document explains the most trustworthy loop. (in Arabic)

27. Jad Alhagh, Ayad Mohammad. (2012). Extent of the necessity of (error) as a pillar of negligent responsibility in the Palestinian Civil Law Project Analytical Study, Journal of the Islamic University for Islamic Studies. (in Arabic)

28. Dojan amush, Mohammad mahmud. (2009). Security barriers in Islamic jurisprudence, Jordan: Dar Al-Nafaes. (in Arabic)

29. Allame Helli, Hasan. (1968). Tazkere Al Foghaha. Qom: Alolbeit Publishing. (in Arabic)

30. Fariz Nosrat, Ahmad Salim. (2006). Amending the condition of contractual liability in the Egyptian Civil Law. Nablus: Najah National University. (in Arabic)

31. Farahi, Ali. (2011). Research in Islamic jurisprudential rules. Tehran: Imam Sadegh University. (in Persian)

32. Qomi, taghi. (No printing date). Three letters. Qom: Mahallati Publishing. (in Arabic)

33. Katuzian, Naser. (2010). Non-contractual requirements. Tehran: University of Tehran. (in Persian)

34. ________________ (2009). Basic Civil Law Lessons from Certain Contracts. Tehran: Ganj-e-Danesh Library. (in Persian)

35. Kashef Al qeta, Hasan. (2001). Anvar Al Feqahat. Najaf: Kashf Cover Foundation. (in Arabic)

36. Lotfi, Hasan. (2000). Causes and Muscat of Compulsory Guarantee. Tehran :Majd. (in Persian)

37. Fazel Lankarani, Mohammad. (1995). Al ghvaed Al Feghhi. Qom: Mer Publishing. (in Arabic)

38. Mameghni, Mohammad Hasan. (1898). Ghayat Al Aamal. Qom: Islamic munitions complex. (in Arabic)

39. Maraghi, Abd Al Fattah. (1996). Al Anavin Al feghhi. Qom: Jameat Almodarresin Publishing. (in Arabic)

40. Marqos, Soleyma. (1988). Adequate explanation of civil law. Cairo: Faculty of Law. (in Arabic)

41. Mashayekhi, Qodrat Allah.(2004). Rules of Jurisprudence. Tehran: Organization for the Study and Compilation of University Humanities Books: Al-Zahra University. (in Persian)

42. Nayini, Mohammad Hosein. (2000). Al Rasael Alfeqhi. Qom: Imam Reza Institute of Islamic Studies Publications. (in Arabic)

43. Naraghi, Ahmad. (1996). Avaed Al Ayam. Qom: Jameat Almodarresin Publishing. (in Arabic)

44. Nekuyi, Mohammad. (2011). Non-liability condition. Tehran: Mizan Publishing. (in Persian)

45. Nuri, Mohades. (1988). Mostadrak Al Vasael. Beirut: Aal al-Bayt Foundation. (in Arabic)

46. Shahrudi, Mahmud. (1996). Research in Fundamentals, Qom:Al-Ghadeer Center for Scientific Studies. (in Arabic)

47. Yazdi, Kazem. (1993). Takmele Orve alvosgha. Qom: Davari Publishing. (in Arabic)

48. Yazdanian,Alireza. (2007). General Rules of Civil Liability, Tehran, Mizan Publishing. (in Persian)

Religious Researches
Volume 17, Issue 1
April 2021
Pages 331-356

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 11 June 2018
  • Revise Date: 24 November 2019
  • Accept Date: 24 November 2019

Share

How to cite

Statistics