Analysis of the Situation of Assimilating Oneself to the Infidels in Sunni & Shi'ite Jurisprudence

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Assistant Professor, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahrekord University, Shahrekord, Iran

Abstract

Assimilating oneself to the infidels, i.e. conforming oneself to a Non-Muslim is totally abominable and there is almost no disagreement in this regard. However, there is no agreement about the situation of the matter in terms of obligatory judgment as well as its generality, specifically about the intension and the knowledge of the assimilated person. And despite the necessity of reporting the disagreements between the Sunni and Shi'ite jurists and their judgments to determine the duties of Islamic Governments when trading with Non-Muslim governments, there is no comprehensive and detailed comparative compiled written text. Accordingly, the author intends to fill in the gap through describing and evaluating different Fatwas of different jurists and to criticize the dominant theory among the Sunnis and believes that assimilating oneself to Non-Muslims in terms of their behaviors and specific beliefs, provided that they are proven to be proprietary, is unlawful only with the aim of promotion of infidelity and undermining Islam and they are not forbidden by themselves. It should be also mentioned that instances of assimilation are not worship-related and are submissive to the customary opinion and consequently depends upon time and place.

Keywords

References

  1. Holly Quran.

    1. Abdoljabbar, S. (2014). Aljamea-o-ssahih lessonan valmasanid. (in Arabic)
    2. Abooavaneh, Y. Mosnad, Beyroot: Dar-o-lmaarefah publishing. (in Arabic)
    3. Aboodavood, S. (2009). Sonan, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Dar-o-rresalat-e-lalamiyah publishing. (in Arabic)
    4. Albani, M. (1985). Erva-o-lqalil, 2nd, Beyroot: Almaktab-o-lIslami Publishing. (in Arabic)
    5. Albani, M. (1992). Jelbab-o-lmarat-e-lmoslemah, 1nd Edition, Omman-Ordon: Almaktabat-o-lIslamiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    6. Alesheikh, M. (1379). Fatava and Rasael, 1nd Edition, Makah: Matbaat-o-lhokomah. (in Arabic)
    7. Alferaj, M. Fath-o-lolalhamid, Riyaz: Dar-o-lakhyar Publishing. (in Arabic)
    8. Ameli (Shahide Avval), M. (1998). Zekr-a-shshiah, 1nd Edition, Qom: Al-o-lbeit Publishing. (in Arabic) 
    9. Ameli (sheikh Bahae), M. (1970). Alhabl-o-lmatin, 1nd Edition, Qom: Basirati Publishing. (in Arabic)
    10. Arafeh, M. (1925). Hokm-o-shshara-e-shsharif  fe lobs-e-lqobah, Almanar, 27, 25-45. (in Arabic)  
    11. Asadi (Allame Helli), H. (1991). Month-a-lmatlab, 1nd Edition, Mashhad: Majma-o-lbohoos-o-lIslamiyah. (in Arabic)
    12. Asadi (Allame Helli), H. (1993). Tazkerat-o-lfoqaha, 1nd Edition, Qom: Al-o-lbeit Instute. (in Arabic)
    13. Asimin, M. (2001). Ashsharh-o-lmomatta, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Daro Ebn-e-ljuzi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    14. Baali, B. (2001). Almanhaj-o-lqavim, 1nd Edition, Makah: Daro alam-e-lfavaed Publishing. (In Arabic)
    15. Barakati, Sh. (2012). Alvelao valbara felIslam, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Dar-o-ddaavat-o-lIslamiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    16. Beihaqi, A. (1925). Assonan-o-lkobra, 1nd Edition, Heydarabad: Daerat-o-lmaref-e-nnezamiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    17. Beihaqi, A. (1989). Shoab-o-liman, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotob-e-lelmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    18. Bokhari, M. (2001). Almosnod-o-ssahih, Riyaz: Daro toq-e-nnajat Publishing. (in Arabic)
    19. Ebne abd-o-lber, Y. (2562). Alestezkar, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotob-e-lelmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    20. Ebne abi sheibah, A. (1988). Alketab-o-lmosnaf, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Maktabat-o-rrosh Publishing. (in Arabic)
    21. Ebne babeveih, M. (1992). Man la yahzoroh-o-lfaqih, 2nd Edition, Qom: Jamee Modaresin Publishing. (in Arabic)
    22. Ebne hazm, M.A. Almohalla, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lfekr Publishing. (in Arabic)
    23. Ebne kasir, Es. (1998). Tafsir-o-lQuran-e-lazim, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotob-e-lelmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    24. Ebne najim, Ab. (1997). Albahr-o-rraeq, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Mohammad Ali Beizoon Publishing. (in Arabic)
    25. Ebne qadamah, Ab. Almoqni, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lketab-e-larabi  Publishing. (in Arabic)
    26. Ebne qasem, M. (1996). Addorar-o-ssonniyah, 6nd Edition, Madinah: Maktabat-o-lmadinah  Publishing. (in Arabic)
    27. Ebne qasem, M. (1997). Almostadrak ala majmue Fatava Ebne teimiyah, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotob Publishing. (in Arabic)
    28. Ebne teimiyah, T. (1988). Alfatav-a-lkobra, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotob-e-lelmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    29. Ebne teimiyah, T. (1998). Eqteza-o-sserat-e-lmostaqim, 7nd Edition, Riyaz: Daro alam-e-lkotob Publishing. (in Arabic)
    30. Eravani, A. (2000). Hashiyat-o-lmakaseb, 2nd Edition, Tehran: Roshddiyeh Publishing. (in Arabic)
    31. Esbahani, A. (1985). Helyat-o-loliya, 4nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lketab-e-larabi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    32. Eshtehardi, A.P. (1996). Madarek-o-lorvat-e-lvosqa, 1nd Edition, Tehran: Dar-o-losvah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    33. Esyoobi, M. (1998). Sharho sonan-e-nnesae. 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Daro Ale boroom  publishing. (in Arabic)
    34. Feize Kashani, M. (1985). Alvafi, 1nd Edition, Esfahan: Maktabat-o-lImam Amir-o-lmomenin Publishing. (in Arabic)
    35. Fuzan, S. (2002). Eanat-o-lmostafid, 3nd Edition, Riyaz: Arresala Instute. (in Arabic)
    36. Haery, J. (1984). Ershad-o-ledad, 1nd Edition, Qom: Elmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    37. Hakim, M.B. (1995). Mostamsak-o-lorvat-e-lvosqa, 1nd Edition, Qom: Dar-o-ttafsir Publishing. (in Arabic)
    38. Hakim, M.S. (2001). Morshed-o-lmoqtareb, 1nd Edition, Najaf ashraf: Ayattolah office. (in Arabic)
    39. Halabi, A. (1993). Ahkam-o-ledayn, 2nd Edition, Beyroot: Almaktabat-o-lIslami Publishing. (in Arabic)
    40. Hasfaki, A. (1994). Addor-o-lmokhtar, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lfekr Publishing. (in Arabic)
    41. Havvi, S. (2033). Alasas fettafsir, 6nd Edition, Qahereh: Dar-o-ssalam Publishing. (in Arabic)
    42. Heisami, N. (1990). Mavared-o-zzaman, 1nd Edition, Dameshq: Dar-o-sseqafat-e-larabiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    43. Helli (Mohaqeq), J. (1987). Almoatabar, 1nd Edition, Qom: Sayyed-o-shshohada Instute. (in Arabic)
    44. Horr Amely, M. (1988). Vasael-o-shshiah, 1nd Edition, Qom: Al-o-lbeit Instute. (in Arabic)
    45. Hoseini Khamenei, a. (1999). Ajvebat-o-lesteftaat, 3nd Edition, Beyroot: AlIslamiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)  
    46. Hoseini Sistani, M. (2002) Alesteftaat, 1nd Edition, Qom: Ayattolah office. (in Arabic)  
    47. Hoseyni, M. (2002). Fiqh-o-lulamah, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Almojtaba lettahqiq vannashr Publishing. (in Arabic)  
    48. Jabae (Shahide sani), Z. (1967). Arrozato-o-lbahiyah, Najaf: Jameat-o-ddiniyah. (in Arabic)
    49. Jabrin, Ab. Tashil-o-laqidat-e-lIslamiyah, 3nd Edition, Riyaz: Dar-o-lasimi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    50. Jalaood, M. (1987). Almovalat valmoadat, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Dar-o-lyaqin Publishing. (in Arabic)
    51. Karaki (mohaqeq), A. (1993). Jameolmaqased, 2nd Edition, Qom: Al-o-lbeit Publishing. (in Arabic)
    52. Kashani. A. (1988). Badae-o-ssanaea, 1nd Edition, Pakestan: Almaktabat-o-lhabibiah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    53. Khansari, J. Attaaliqat alarrozat-e-lbahiyah, 1nd Edition, Qom: Arrazaviyah 
    54. Khue. A. (1992). Mesbah-o-lfeqahah (Almakaseb), 1nd Edition, Qom: Davari Publishing. (in Arabic)
    55. Koleini, M. (2008). Alkafi, 1nd Edition, Qom: Dar-o-lhadis Publishing. (in Arabic) 
    56. Majlesi (Allameh). M.B. (1982). Behar-o-lanvar, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Daro Ehya-e-ttoras Publishing. (in Arabic)   
    57. Majlesi (Allameh). M.B. (1985). Malaz-o-lakhyar, 1nd Edition, Qom: Ayat-o-llah Marashi Library.
    58. Makarme Shirazi, N. (2006). Alfata-a-ljadidah, 2nd Edition, Imam Ali Religious Islamic school. (in Arabic) 
    59. Manavi, M. (1994). Feiz-o-lqadir, 2nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotod-e-lelmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)      
    60. Mardavi, A. (1998). Alensaf, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Daro Ehya-e-ttoras Publishing. (in Arabic)
    61. Marvazi, M. (1987). Assonah, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Alkotob-o-sseqafi Instute. (in Arabic)
    62. Montazeri, H.A. (1994). Derasaton felmakaseb-e-lmoharamah, 1nd Edition, Qom: Tafakkor Publishing. (in Arabic)     
    63. Monzari, Z. (1986). Mokhtsaro sahihe Moslem, 6nd Edition, Beyroot: Almaktab-o-lIslami  Publishing. (in Arabic)   
    64. Moqadam, M. (1984). Adellato Tahrime Halq-e-llehyah, 4nd Edition, Koveit: Dar-o-larqam Publishing. (in Arabic)     
    65. Mostafavi, H. (1981). Attahqiq fe kalamat-e-lQuran, 1nd Edition, Tehran: Markaz-o-lketab Publishing. (in Arabic)
    66. Neishaburi, M. Sahih Moslem, Beyroot: Daro Ehya-e-ttoras-e-larabi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    67. Nesae, A. (1990). Sonan-o-nnesa-e-lkobra, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotob-e-lelmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    68. Noora (mohades), H. (1987). Mostadrak-o-lvasael, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Al-o-lbeit Publishing. (in Arabic)
    69. Noori. A. Almosnad-o-ljame-o-lmoalal, Almaktabat-o-shshamelah Software. (in Arabic)
    70. okbari (Sheikh Mofid), M. (1992). Almoqneeh, 1nd Edition, Qom: Intrrnational Congeress of Sheikh Mofid. (in Arabic)
    71. Qabanji, H. (2000). Mosnad-o-lImam Ali, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Alalami Instute. (in Arabic) 
    72. Qahtani, M. Alvela valbara felIslam, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Daro tayyebah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    73. Ravandi, F. (1998). Annavader, 1nd Edition, Qom: Dar-o-lhadis Publishing. (in Arabic)
    74. Religious Islamic school. (in Arabic)  
    75. Rohani, M.S. (1992). Fiqh-o-ssadeq, 3nd Edition, Qom: Dar-o-lketab Publishing. (in Arabic)
    76. Rohani, M.S. (1997). Menhaj-o-lfiqahah, 4nd Edition, Qom: Elmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    77. Sabki, T. Fatav-a-ssabki, Beyroot: Dar-o-lmaarefah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    78. Salman, A. (2003). Mavared-o-zzaman, 30nd Edition, Makah: Maktabat-o-lmasjed-e-nnabavi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    79. Sanane, M. (1959). Sobol-o-ssalam, 4nd Edition, Mesr: Mostaf-a-lbabi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    80. Sarakhsi, Sh. (1996). Sharho asseir-e-lkabir, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lkotob-e-lelmiyah Publishing. (in Arabic)
    81. Send, M. (2005). Osas-o-nnezam-e-ssiyasi end-a-lImamiyah, 1nd Edition, Qom: Baqiyat Publishing. (in Arabic)
    82. Seymari, M. (1999). Qayat-o-lmaram, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lhadi Publishing. (in Arabic)
    83. Shaaood, A. (2012) Mafhoom-e-lvala valbara felQuran vassonnah, 1nd Edition. (in Arabic)
    84. Shahidi, F. (1996). Hedayat-o-ttaleb, 2nd Edition, Qom: Dar-o-lketab Publishing. (in Arabic) 
    85. Shahrestani, A. (1999). Vozu-o-nnabi, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Ber-o-labd Publishing. (in Arabic)
    86. Sheybani, Ah. (2000). Mosnad, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Arrasalah Instute. (in Arabic) 
    87. Shokani. M. (1973). Mosooat-o-rrad al-a-lmazaheb-e-lfekriyat-e-lmoaserah. (in Arabic) 
    88. Shokani. M. (1973). Neyl-o-latar, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lhadl Publishing. (in Arabic)  
    89. Sobhani (a), J. Resalaton fe tasir-e-zzaman valmakan, 1nd Edition, Qom. (in Arabic)
    90. Sobhani (b) Selelat-o-lmasael-e-lfiqhiyah, 1nd Edition, Qom. (in Arabic)
    91. Tabasi, N. (2001). Somo Ashura, 1nd Edition, Qom: Manshurat-o-lahd. (in Arabic)
    92. Tarmazi, M. (1983). Sonan, 1nd Edition, Beyroot: Dar-o-lfekr Publishing. (in Arabic)
    93. Tayalasi, S. (1998). Sharho mosnade Abi davood, 1nd Edition, Riyaz: Daro hajr Publishing. (in Arabic) 
    94. Yazdi, M. (1994). Fiqh-o-lQuran, 1nd Edition, Qom: Esmaeliyan Instute. (in Arabic)
Religious Researches
Volume 17, Issue 1
April 2021
Pages 175-203

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 28 April 2019
  • Revise Date: 24 November 2019
  • Accept Date: 24 November 2019

Share

How to cite

Statistics